Bolts & Dolts: Preseason Week 4
The preseason is over and I don't think it's far-fetched to call it a success for the Chargers. The only true weakness that anybody saw was with the offensive line and, as expected, they got better each week.
Last night, with a handful of spots open to 10-15 players, guys were fighting to have a job today. After the jump, find out who played well and who played poorly in this week's Bolts & Dolts feature.
Bolts
Offense
Billy Volek - 8/13, 103 yards, 1 TD. I don't think there has ever been a time where Chargers were more confident in their backup QB, even when Rivers was the backup, than right now. Billy really seems to have hit his stride as a QB. Not only does this make all of us rest easy if something were to happen to Rivers, Volek could be used as trade bait during the season or in the offseason if the Chargers need to fill a hole. Preseason Stats - 29/41, 393 yards, 3 TDs, 0 INT.
Gartrell Johnson - 20 carries, 85 yards. A solid 4.3 rushing average on the night. Gartrell calmed a lot of people who were terrified of the idea of the team keeping him while getting rid of Michael Bennett. Not only did he show good power-running by breaking a lot of tackles, he has shown improvement throughout the preseason and will hopefully continue to get better. Preseason Stats - 48 carries, 184 yards rushing, 7 catches, 57 yards rec.
Michael Bennett - 8 carries, 30 yards. Well he certainly sold the 49ers announcers, didn't he? Here's what Bennett has going against him. One, he's old. 31 in running back years is like 40 in quarterback years. You have to be very special to be a starting RB at 30+ years of age, due to effectiveness and health. Bennett has always had health issues, even when he was the starting RB for Minnesota, so there's no saying that he could step in for an injured LT and stay healthy himself. Two, he's expensive. That's not really his fault, but veteran players cost more than rookies (Gartrell) and players in their first few years in the league (Mike Tolbert). Three, if you keep him instead of Gartrell you're left with a RB rotation of LaDainian Tomlinson (30 years old), Darren Sproles (5'6"), Bennett (31 years old) and Jacob Hester (a FB). Would you like one young, exciting guy in there to be the one to take some of the pounding and be a project for the future? The team would. Four, if the team keeps Bennett instead of Tolbert they're sacrificing a good special teams player. With kickoff coverage being a weakness for the Bolts, this is an area they should be wary of taking good players away from. Preseason Stats - 26 carries, 89 yards rushing, 2 rushing TDs, 5 catches, 112 yards rec, 1 receiving TD.
Kassim Osgood - 1 catch, 39 yards, 1 TD. Osgood presented match-up problems for the 49ers secondary when he was in there. The TD catch was not an easy one and he caused at least one defensive pass interference penalty down the field as well. Good game by KO. Preseason Stats - 1 catch, 39 yards, 1 TD.
Kory Sperry - 2 catches, 29 yards, 1 TD. I was raving about this kid after my day at Chargers training camp a month ago. When he wasn't trying to block he really stood out. He's tall with long arms, has soft hands and has good speed for a TE. Unfortunately, his good game last night may have caught somebody's attention which might keep him off the Chargers practice squad. Preseason Stats - 2 catches, 29 yards, 1 TD.
Nate Kaeding - 4/4 FGs, 2/2 PATs. Last night Nate made it all seem too easy. He lined up and made kicks of 28, 36, 47 and 51 yards without breaking much of a sweat. Considering he did it in the stadium he's planning to play at least 8 games in this season, it was an excellent sign. If he can continue to knock them down from 50 yards, I think he's got a chance at making the Pro Bowl in 2009. Preseason Stats - 6/8 FGs (2/2 from 50+ yards), 9/9 PATs, 57.7 kickoff average yards, 1 perfect onside kick.
Defense
Antwan Applewhite - 4 tackles, 1 sack. Antwan was everywhere last night. Rushing the passer, stopping the run and even playing some coverage. It seemed like he was out there as part of the "second team" defense, ahead of Jyles Tucker. So if anyone is going to be cut, it may be Tucker. Applewhite has played his heart out in the preseason and given the coaches every reason to keep him. Just look at this stat-line... Preseason Stats - 12 tackles, 1 sack, 3 passes defended, 1 interception, 1 forced fumble.
Larry English - 2 tackles, 1 pass defended. I'm convinced, this kid is awesome. Part of me has always been secretly worrying that he wasn't worth than #16 pick, but he puts pressure on the quarterback with amazing consistency. I can't wait to see what he can do when Merriman and/or Phillips are on the field with him. Preseason Stats - 2 tackles, 1 pass defended.
Brandon Siler - 5 tackles. Siler played a good chunk of the game last night and performed as you'd image. He was strong against the run and shaky in coverage. I don't know if that will ever get any better, but he doesn't make for a terrible 4th ILB and special teamer. Preseason Stats - 11 tackles.
Dolts
Offense
Jacob Hester - 1 carry, 2 yards, 3 catches, 15 receiving yards. I hope the coaching staff is as sick as seeing him run the ball as I am. He has no speed, he has no moves and his power is just average. I like him as a blocker and a receiver, but I do not want to see him getting more than 1 carry a game in the regular season. Preseason Stats - 8 carries, 25 rushing yards, 6 catches, 26 receiving yards.
Malcom Floyd - 1 catch, 9 yards. I counted at least two balls that should've been caught and weren't by Malcom last night. Not a huge deal, but even in the preseason he has to know that a dropped ball will make the team's QBs less eager to throw a ball his way. Preseason Stats - 8 catches, 127 yards, 1 TD.
Craig "Buster" Davis - DNP. Injured? Again? Buster is making it harder and harder to defend him. If he hadn't already had a good preseason I'd be worried about him getting cut today. Preseason Stats - 5 catches, 102 yards.
Charly Martin - 1 catch, 5 yards. For those of you hoping that Charly would have a bad performance that would help him to make it to the Chargers practice squad, you're in luck! Not only did Charly show no sign of creating separation against a poor SF secondary, but he went "alligator arms" on a pass over the middle. Preseason Stats - 7 catches, 88 yards.
Defense
Kevin Burnett - STAY HEALTHY. That was your one job and you couldn't even do that. For those of you interested in what a stringer is, here's the Wikipedia page for it. It is essentially a pinched nerve that can cause either weakness or pain, but will typically go away if the player is relaxed and treated with heat and ice. Considering Kevin Acee reported on his twitter that Burnett was walking around the locker room smiling after the game, we can assume his stinger was gone by the end of the game. Preseason Stats - 17 tackles.
Kevin Ellison - 2 tackles. Siler Jr. This kid could be a tackling machine, but his poor job at coverage and reading the play will keep him off the field until he gets better. Preseason Stats - 10 tackles, 1 forced fumble.
Do you have any thoughts about Bolts From The Blue? Any tips you want to send our way? Whenever you have something to say, don't hesitate to e-mail me directly.
2 recs |
20 comments
|
Comments
excellent summary
Cuts today 3PM pacific
by Stephen (shaynes41) on Sep 5, 2009 7:31 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
noted
"I did not invent the wheel, I was the crooked spoke adjacent." - Aesop Rock
by John Gennaro on Sep 5, 2009 10:00 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Ellison will be cut
He’s not ready to play ILB yet and his coverage skills take him out of the running for a safety position. Plus, Gregory had a great game in coverage so I can he acting as a 4th CB if needed. With Gregory and Oliver floating as back-up safeties Ellison is expendable.
by riversformvp on Sep 5, 2009 8:22 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Doubt it
If they’re keeping 3 DBs, they’ll certainly keep 5 Safeties.
"I did not invent the wheel, I was the crooked spoke adjacent." - Aesop Rock
by John Gennaro on Sep 5, 2009 10:01 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Gartrell
I would have put him in the Dolts side of the ledger. We was awful until he got to play against the scrubs where he could finally run someone over. Against the better players in the first half he looked slow and couldn’t break a tackle to save his life. Against the same competition Michael Bennet looked like a bonafide NFL RB. Throw in on top of that an easy pass that was dropped. This was not a good game for Gartrell.
Wisdom can not be cultivated through ignorance of information.
by Wonko on Sep 5, 2009 9:01 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
First half comparisons (every run)
Bennett
M. Bennett rushed to the left for 7 yard gain
M. Bennett rushed up the middle for 1 yard gain
M. Bennett rushed up the middle for 10 yard gain
M. Bennett rushed up the middle for 1 yard gain
M. Bennett rushed to the right for 3 yard gain
M. Bennett rushed to the left for 1 yard gain
M. Bennett rushed to the left for 6 yard gain
M. Bennett rushed to the left for 1 yard gain
(Where’s the consistency? Every other carry is for 1 yard)
Johnson (just the first half carries)
G. Johnson rushed to the left for 4 yard gain
G. Johnson rushed to the left for 3 yard gain
G. Johnson rushed to the right for 5 yard gain
G. Johnson rushed to the left for 3 yard gain
G. Johnson rushed to the left for 1 yard gain
G. Johnson rushed up the middle for no gain
G. Johnson rushed up the middle for 8 yard gain
G. Johnson rushed up the middle for no gain
Did Bennett really perform significantly better? Also, consider that when Gartrell was brought in everyone but Vasquez on the O-line went out.
"I did not invent the wheel, I was the crooked spoke adjacent." - Aesop Rock
by John Gennaro on Sep 5, 2009 10:00 AM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
Time will tell
In my opinion Bennett did significantly outperform Gartrell this pre season. Last night was by far Gartrell’s best game and it was by no means spectacular.
Maybe Gartrell will surprise me and down the road he will turn into a quality NFL back. But I don’t think that he is big enough to be the “big power back” that everyone thinks he can become. He does not have the speed to make big game changing plays, and while he may become one he is not currently thought of as a great receiver out of the backfield. I do not see him as LTs eventual replacement either. I do not believe that G.M.s around the league are anxiously waiting by their phones in hopes that they can snag Gartrell if the Chargers try to put him on the practice squad, but we will never know because it looks like the Chargers are going to get rid of Bennett instead.
If they can keep Gartrell and he develops thats great, I just hope it is not at the cost of losing Bennett this season.
by JeromeB on Sep 5, 2009 10:46 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Since its preseason
I’m going to trust my eyes over the stats in this case. Gartrell is supposed to be a power runner, but he doesn’t have size for it or the speed to outrun the DLs that chasing him. He’s going to struggle in the NFL until he gets bigger and shows better leverage. I’m not even sure that anyone would pick him up if we sent him to the PS, he’s just not NFL caliber yet.
Wisdom can not be cultivated through ignorance of information.
by Wonko on Sep 5, 2009 2:40 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
I think Gartrell showed tremendous promise last night.
He was breaking tackles left and right, fighting for the extra yards. As far as I can tell, he has a few correctable faults that will make him into the back we expected him to be.
- Hitting the holes right. This could be argued as a lack of vision but I think it might just be a college-to-nfl transition thing. Needs to learn when to be patient and find the hold and when to slam it through the middle as per the play design. Should find this with experience.
- Stay low to finish runs. He hits the hole low and powerful but once he gets into stride he runs too upright. Biggest example was when he should have finished a run into the end zone after breaking through the first resistance, but was stuffed because he was standing up. Can be coached.
Two small things that should make a big difference in a power back. He needs to learn when and how to use his power.
I saw enough to keep him on the roster.
by gman87 on Sep 5, 2009 10:22 AM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
Gartrell
was anything but powerful.
Wisdom can not be cultivated through ignorance of information.
by Wonko on Sep 5, 2009 2:40 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
he had a couple powerfull runs
where he bowled over a few guys and bounced off a few others. Still not real consistent, but I think he may be getting it.
by Stephen (shaynes41) on Sep 5, 2009 2:48 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Like I said before
The caliber of players he bowled over were not up to par with the ones that were easily taking him down earlier in the game.
Wisdom can not be cultivated through ignorance of information.
by Wonko on Sep 5, 2009 3:14 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Stuffed twice at the goal line,SORRY!!!
NEVER MISS A GAME,WHETHER BY BEING THERE OR WATCHING AT HOME,FO SHO!!!
by Gorditoe1 on Sep 5, 2009 11:21 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Gartrell seems like a slow starter
LT is kind of a slow starter too. Of course once LT gets warmed up there is no stopping him.
I don’t think back-ups can afford to be cold starters. They are going to get limited and situational reps. Turner and Sproles have both made the best of their limited reps in the past. Maybe in another year at the Pro-level Gartrell will figure out how to play at the correct speed right from the first snap.
by Trendsearcher on Sep 6, 2009 3:47 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Great Point
Gartrell proved tonight that if he is needed to fill in for LT against the 49ers back ups (or guys who are no longer on the team), that he is more than capable of doing the job.
But I think that Bennett has proven this pre season that if LT misses a game or two, he is the man to fill in for him. I hope the Chargers keep the player that can best help them win this season.
Gartrell may or may not turn into an NFL player one day, Bennett already is one.
by JeromeB on Sep 5, 2009 9:19 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Gartrell- practice squad
Hate to say it, but I think Gartrell should be put on the practice squad. He hasn’t impressed me in the preseason. i understand about the salary factor, but if we cut bennett I think we will see him twice this year (broncos). You know about the broncos and running backs. And with orton as their qb, I see the broncos running the ball alot. Even if LT stays healthy, I would still let bennett have some carries. But, if yuour right and they cut him, someone will pick him up (broncos).
by irishlad on Sep 5, 2009 10:04 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
First, that was Shanahan and the cut-blocking scheme that made those RBs good. They don’t have either of those anymore.
Secondly, the Broncos have Moreno, Buckhalter and Arrington. They don’t need another RB, and if they grabbed him he’d be inactive most weeks.
Gartrell probably wouldn’t make it to the practice squad. Another team would claim him off waivers. 4th round picks don’t grow on trees.
"I did not invent the wheel, I was the crooked spoke adjacent." - Aesop Rock
by John Gennaro on Sep 5, 2009 10:33 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Broncos might not want either back
I believe that the Broncos got rid of Arrington quite a while back, but they do have Buckhalter, Moreno, Lamont Jordan and Peyton Hillis, so I don’t think that they would pick up either back.
by JeromeB on Sep 5, 2009 10:52 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Crap
I forgot, Arrington failed his physical.
You’re right though. They’re set at RB with who they have.
"I did not invent the wheel, I was the crooked spoke adjacent." - Aesop Rock
by John Gennaro on Sep 5, 2009 12:56 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
I am in the pro-bennet camp and think Tolbert should be the one cut
However, if our running backs are LT, Sproles, Hester, Johnson, and Tolbert, then I think we are in better shape than last year. LT and Sproles are the same, Hester and Tolbert have another year under their belt, and Johnson is a high potential and good grind it out guy.
I still feel we would be better off with LT Sproles, Hester, Johnson, and Bennett, but I think either way we are improved at RB from last year.
by Stephen (shaynes41) on Sep 5, 2009 2:46 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs

by 
















